Councillors scrutinised over school cuts in Chesterfield

Friday, December 7th, 2018 1:27pm

By Eddie Bisknell- Local Democracy Reporter @EddieBisk

Derbyshire County Council has faced a barrage from concerned teachers and students regarding the ongoing impact of funding cuts to their schools.

During the full council meeting in Matlock on Wednesday, teachers stated that their funding was falling by hundreds of pounds per pupil, they cannot properly cater for children with special educational needs, one said that that they could no longer offer music as a class, and a student says her school – now an academy – could not afford to give lined paper to its pupils.

Head teacher at Chesterfield’s Brampton Primary School, Wayne Parkinson, kicked off the debate.

He said that his school has 13 pupils who require Education, Health and Care Plans – a legal document which lays out the specific support that these children require.

Mr Parkinson says that the school only has funding for four pupils.

He asked how many schools have five or more pupils on EHC Plans.
Cllr Alex Dale, the cabinet member for young people, said that 32 schools had five or more pupils on EHC plans – excluding special schools – accounting for 9.1 per cent of those under the council’s control.

He said that he would continue to lobby government funding more funding for pupils with special educational needs.
“It is a key area of concern for us,” he says.

However, he said, “we are managing relatively better than some of our neighbours”.

Deborah Turner, from the National Union of Teachers, said that the current funding crisis was putting vulnerable and disadvantaged pupils, as well as those with special educational needs, at risk.

Cllr Dale said the authority “has a robust policy of risk analysis and providing support for these children”.

He said that there is a “whole school approach to mental health, but there is always more we can do, I fully accept that”.

Cllr Dale continued: “We will continue to lobby government. We don’t think the new school funding formula goes far enough. Derbyshire has 50 per cent less funding than some others.

“The Chancellor says that schools will get £400 million, but that could always be more.”

Students from Chestefield’s Brookfield Secondary School, Katie Hibbert, Lily Beard and Katie Bargh, also had a question for councillors.

Ms Bargh spoke at the meeting.

She said: “The cuts and changes to school funding have resulted in many schools converting to academies, including ours.  

“Since the change, Brookfield has gone from being an outstanding school under local authority control to one that is classed as inadequate and will be sold off to a multi academy trust.

“As pupils, we have seen the impact that these cuts have had.

“Most recently, the school has announced that they are no longer able to give out lined paper.”

She suggested that the quality of education provided should be a greater priority than the ideological pressure to convert a school into an academy.

In response, Cllr Dale said: “The quality of education is paramount. Any decision is made in the best interest of each school.

“When Brampton converted to an academy in 2011 there was a financial benefit – but that is not the case now.”

He said that he could not comment on the academy’s spending, it was down to them to decide how to do this.

However, he said that it is set to receive £100 more per pupil per year – as it would if it was still under local authority control.

He said: “Like many schools in the county, performance is fluctuating, it is not necessarily down to its operating model (academy versus local authority control) – there are other variables.

“In this instance, I believe the school’s rating is entirely as a result of Ofsted finding quite significant safeguarding issues.”

Ben Riggott, head teacher of Parkside Community School, near Chesterfield, had intended on giving a statement at the meeting but could not because he had to cover a PE class for an absent teacher – and the school could not afford a cover teacher.

In a statement read out at the meeting, he stated that the school had lost £300 per pupil.

He said funding cuts had also led to the school no longer being able to teach music and staff redundancies.

Cllr Dale said that he would continue lobbying government and local MPs for funding as part of the F40 – a group of the lowest-funded education authorities in England.

Lisa Tunnell, from the National Education Union, said that school funding cuts were having a strong impact.

She said: “In Chesterfield, this has meant support staff redundancies, reduction in support for SEN students, bigger class sizes, loss of leadership positions, increased workload for remaining staff, teachers covering absent colleagues due to lack of money for supply and the removal of pastoral provision such as careers advice, mental health support and counselling services.”

More from Local